Proven Sudoku

Techniques / Single-digit patterns

Empty Rectangle

Also called ER, Turbot Fish (box-based form), Hinge.

New to this shorthand? How to read a sudoku grid explains r4c7, houses, candidates and the rest.

What it means

In one box, all the homes for a digit sit in one row and one column. The box needs that digit somewhere. So it is in that row part or that column part. Team that up with a pair of homes elsewhere and you can rule the digit out.

The exact rule, for stronger players

The rule, stated exactly: For digit d and a box B, if the candidates of d in B all lie in one row and one column of B (leaving an empty rectangle of four cells), the intersection acts as a grouped node. Combined with a conjugate pair on d elsewhere, d is eliminated from the cell seeing both the far end of the pair and the relevant line of B.

What it removes: Remove d from the cell seeing both the conjugate partner and the grouped box node.

Why it works: Whichever of the row or column within B holds d, the box node is true as a group. That grouped node forms a strong link, and the rest is a length-four chain identical to the other Turbot forms.

Worked examples

These come from real Proven Sudoku boards. Nobody drew them by hand to make the pattern look neat. Each one is checked first, so the board is one you could really meet, the pattern is really there, and every digit it rules out is really wrong.

Sudoku grid showing Empty Rectangle. b3 must hold 2, and every place it could go lies in r2 or c7. Combined with the 2 link between r5c8 and r5c7, that clears 2 from r7c7.
b3 must hold 2, and every place it could go lies in r2 or c7. Combined with the 2 link between r5c8 and r5c7, that clears 2 from r7c7.
Sudoku grid showing Empty Rectangle. b2 must hold 1, and every place it could go lies in r2 or c6. Combined with the 1 link between r3c3 and r7c3, that clears 1 from r7c5.
b2 must hold 1, and every place it could go lies in r2 or c6. Combined with the 1 link between r3c3 and r7c3, that clears 1 from r7c5.

Learn these first

Related single-digit patterns

How often does it come up?

Our rough estimate: common, but frequently missed because the name describes the empty cells rather than the candidate cells.

Play today's puzzle or read how difficulty is graded.